Parte 2. Dream (Better Dreaming)
Beware! Contains heavy spoilers for Xenoblade Chronicles 1, Dandara and Many Nights a Whisper.
(If you haven’t read this, here’s Part 1)
The song begins:
“Tell the kids they’re breaking all the rules
Breed a generation full of fools
thinking they are free from the approvals of a faceless father”
Xenoblade Chronicles 1
Visions, QuickTime Events and Self-Determination
The Incantation invites us to revoke Late Stage Capitalism’s influence, to stop asking for its approval. Dreaming a Reality free of its power implies giving up living by its rules. I lived that once, when I was Shulk in the first Xenoblade Chronicles.
The game is about Visions and Willpower. The beginning of its development also was; Tetsuya Takahashi was on his way to the MonolithSoft offices and was overcome by a Vision: two rival gods wound each other to death and their bodies become worlds that spring life, peoples, societies; also destined to eternal war. The main symbol of the game is a red sword, the Mondado, it gives its user Visions about the future.
Visions are one of the main gameplay Mechanics. They consist of short cinematics that stop the battle and reveal what will happen in a few seconds. A Vision of a mortal blow gives you a few seconds to summon a shield. Visions allow us to change the future, they’re the only ting standing between victory and sure death.
Three quarters into the game there’s a major plot twist, beware spoilers. The Monado represents the Will of one of the two battling gods, every Vision you’ve had during the game has tricked you into helping his plan: reabsorbing all life that has flowed from him. According to his logic, you’re just a blob of his energy, who are you to defy your god?
After a few moments of despair, Shulk is capable of crystallizing his own Will into a new Monado. From that moment on, the dynamic changes: Visions stop activating automatically and we can only access them if we succeed in doing a quicktime event. This simple change mechanically reflects how Dreaming of a new future is forged with every single decision. We experience this intensely in the final battle against the god, when a single attack can wipe our the whole team.
Xenoblade allowed me to live that. I understood that continuing to be on “autopilot” means participating in the systems at play, but that we can manifest our own Willpower to Dream of our own futures.
The song continues:
“Dreaming our lives will stay the same
Dreaming that we will win the game
Dreaming it all will stay the same
But only so much better”
Dandara
Dreams, Quick Travel and the end of Capitalism
The incantation invites us to embrace the process of Dreaming, understanding that even when nothing changes Dreaming still improves our lives. I lived that once, when I was Dandara in The Salt.
The game cannot have a better introduction. It tells us that: “The Salt was once in a beautiful peace. Creation and Intention merged together into learning and growth. But like cancer, a golden idea grew. The balance broke, And oppression came. When all seem lost... From the Crib of Creation, A new hope awakened!”
Inspired by the historical figure of Dandara Dos Palmares: extraordinary leader, warrior and strategist who fought against slavery in Brasil from her quilombo —large communities of African peoples who freed themselves from slavery— around the 1600s. Her name carries deep meaning in the fight against oppression and afrofeminist resistance.
Developed in Belo Horizonte, a Brazilian city with a rich history of social activism and civil participation, by João Brant and Lucas Mattos under their studio Long Hat House. This atypical metroidvania lets us take the place of Dandara, a representation of those ideals of revolutionary freedom.
You navigate the world of the Salt, as you witness the destruction that this golden idea has wrought until, finally, you reach the Golden Fortress at the heart of Intention. Square and impenetrable, its borders are rails where you are attacked mercilessly by golden indestructible gatling guns. You find a two-pixel wide breach, but there’s no way to fit through there. Someone mentions the Lord of Dreams and tells you that he had his own way into the Fortress, suggesting “If this is our dream, why don't we search his Lands?”
Dandara achieves an exquisite marriage of its Mechanics and narrative design. Starting with its peculiar movement system: there’s no gravity, Dandara moves through space by jumping diagonally between nearby surfaces. If a surface is too far, we can’t jump, as if to say that Revolution is taken one step at a time, solidly, without leaping into the void. We attack enemies with Freedom Arrows that Dandara “generates from her purpose”.
Finally, after exploring the Dream Lands you acquire a new Mechanic: Dreaming. What is, mechanically a simple quick travel between save points is narratively resignified in a masterful manner. You Dream yourself inside the Golden Fortress, finally breaching it. The game does not become easier. The golden turrets keep attacking us mercilessly, but we’re in. We’ve overcome an obstacle that seemed physically impossible, we can move forward.
Dandara allowed me to live that. I understood that Dreaming is the only way forward when every way seems blocked, that it is the only way to dismantle once and for all “the golden idea”.
The song howls:
“Oh, but only cowards
will not entertain imaginings of self-erasure”
Many Nights a Whisper
Holding, Letting Go and Catapulting Doubt
The Incantation invites us to invoke the bravery to transit change, despite the fear that it might transform us, despite the discomfort or having the odds stacked against us. I lived that once, when I was the Dreamer in Many Nights a Whisper.
The game explores the weight of Dreams. Inspired by the legendary Barcelona 92’ Olympics Opening Ceremony: when Antonio Rebollo made the sacred Olympic Flame fly out from his quiver and light the Olympic Torch, suspended 61 meters into the air, before the eyes of the whole world. The game developers Deconstructeam and Selkie Harbor, both in Valencia, explore the pressure that is generated by doubt, the weight of expectations and the fear of risking everything in a single moment.
You embody The Dreamer, chosen for a ritual that happens every ten years. The ritual consists of firing a fireball into a sacred chalice: if you succeed, the Dreams of your people will be granted, if you fail none of them ever will. You only have one shot. You’ve been training in mind and body for the last 10 years, the day is almost here.
The balance of the game is simple and elegant. You start with a very weak slingshot and the chalice is very far away. Each Wish you accept makes your slingshot stronger, but you know what if you fail then that dream will never be realized, no matter how simple. The Wishes are very diverse, from banal to reality-transforming. Do you only accept the lame ones in case you fail, or do you accept the important ones and believe in yourself? In any case, if you don’t accept enough Wishes you can’t reach the chalice so you must decide.
The Mechanics feed off each other generating a virtuous cycle of asphyxiating tension. Controller wise, the main action the player does is holding a button. This simple action, having to hold the button for a few seconds, is supported by the psychic processes behind doubt which is brilliantly mechanized in two modes of play. When you’re practicing archery, there’s no pointer on screen, you aim, press the button and… no, maybe a bit further up… ugh, I dunno… and you let go of the button. At night, you listen to a Wish, you doubt a bit but you press the button and… no, maybe not this one, and you let go.
The whole game is 60-90 minutes, but you feel the weight of a lifetime. As the days advance you load yourself with responsibility; you start reaching the chalice, your heart starts racing. In that moment of enormous pressure, the Dreamer reaches a vital realization. Spoilers incoming. She understands that the result doesn’t matter because the ritual will end either way, and after it does she will be a different person living a different life, she understands that “my only option is doing my best”.
Many Nights a Whisper allowed me to live that. I understood that even though Dreaming can be hard, even though the weight of responsibility can feel asphyxiating, we are all people doing the best we can and that simple fact is enough and is invaluable. The most important part is daring to step into change without being paralyzed by the results, it’s having the bravery to Dream.
The song ends:
“Tell the kids to listen to themselves
Dreaming of life without the noise
Dreaming the strangest strains of voice
Dreaming that I might have a choice
And that I’d choose much better…
…So much better.”
To close off, the Incantation invites us to listen to our own voice and Dream of a life “without the noise”, with the possibility of infinite diversity. It invites us to Dream that we might have a choice so that we can make it a Reality. That’s the way the Incantation ends.
I decided on these three games —from different genres and cultural origins— because in each case I felt part of my Magic return to me. Our Incantations can counteract the necropower of Late Stage Capitalism, they can free other Dreamers and give them back their Magic. I’ve chosen these three examples, but there’s many more and hundreds more to come.
Dreaming is up to all of us. The function of artists is to inspire Dreams and unite them in incubating them. The Dreamers of Videogames wield an enormous power, I don’t want you to forget it or to take it for granted. If this text inspired one person, it will have been worth it and we’ll be closer to free ourselves from this heartbreaking Reality, to Dreaming of another Reality that can be better. So much better.
Notes
- Because of the way I separated the text it's not explicitly written here but the song is Better Dreaming, from the homonymous album by Tune-Yards.
- For this piece I was inspired by Marta Trivi’s talk “La legitimidad del videojuego en el marco de la industria cultural” (“The Legitimacy of Video Games within the Cultural Industry Framework”), for Guadalindie 2024. It is marvelous, you can see it in the Guadalindie Twitch or on Youtube.
- Deeply inspired by: the Great Dreamer Ursula K LeGuin, all of Tune-Yards' music, “Dysphoria mundi” by Paul B. Preciado, “Utopia Is Not An Island” by Layla Martínez, “Capitalist Realism” by Mark Fisher y, of course, Metaphor ReFantazio developed by Studio Zero within Atlus.
- I initially thought of choosing one song for each game, but finally decided to stick to one single song to reduce complexity. I still think the songs really fit the narrative and energy of each game, they would have been: ‘Swarm’ for Xenoblade Chronicles, ‘Better Dreaming’ for Dandara and ‘Sanctuary’ for Many Nights a Whisper.
Leave a Reply